What strategies can enhance community in my online course?

Enhancing Online Education

This KB document is part of a larger collection of documents on enhancing online education. More Enhancing Online Education resources.

Part 3: Fostering Community

Overview 

Establishing a welcoming online learning environment is only the first step. In order to promote student success, you’ll need to continually provide opportunities for students to engage - in other words, active learning experiences. Active learning is an important part of any course, regardless of delivery modality. Online learning offers a variety of innovative ways to engage students. Here you will explore active learning strategies, identify new opportunities for interaction, and discover approaches to facilitating asynchronous discussions that you can use in your course.

What is "engagement"?

There is no shortage of evidence highlighting the importance of engagement for deep learning. Major (2015) argues that “student engagement is a prerequisite to learning” (p. 211). It is important to clearly define engagement so that we can look for new opportunities in online learning. In its broadest sense, engagement might equate to attentiveness. In a more specific interpretation, engagement might require interaction with and/or application of a concept. According to Major (2015) student engagement consists of four interrelated factors (pp. 209-210):

  1. Motivation: the drive to learn deriving from internal desires and/or external pressures
  2. Attention: the ability to focus on a task 
  3. Involvement: time and energy devoted to learning
  4. Intellectual effort: skills to engage in deep learning approaches (beyond memorization)

Depending on your own approach to teaching in a face-to-face classroom, teaching online may require innovative and varied approaches to engagement. In online learning environments engagement can (and should) be present throughout the learning experience - from the orientation to the final evaluation. Locating opportunities for independent and collaborative activities will strengthen engagement and deepen learning. This document will focus on three forms of interaction: 

Learning objectives

After reviewing this material, you will be able to:

[Note: The content you will explore here has been modified from its original version as an asynchronous micro-course offered to faculty in August 2022. Some language found in the following text and/or videos may refer to this course. Future offerings can be found at ctlm.wisc.edu/deepen-your-skills]

Active Learning Online

Background

This resource is meant to aid in the identification, practice, and implementation of research-based active learning approaches. It can be used in both online and face-to-face learning environments. This guide should help you to create and recognize opportunities to integrate active learning activities that facilitate desired student learning outcomes into your course in both planned and dynamic ways.

|

Case Studies

The Case Studies approach has student teams review a written study of a real-world scenario containing a field-related problem or situation. Case studies usually include a brief history of the situation and present a dilemma the main character is facing. Team members apply course concepts to identify and evaluate alternative approaches to solving the problem.

View Details

Minute Paper/Muddiest Point

The Minute Paper/Muddiest Point approaches have students write quick responses to a question to help instructors gain insight or understanding of content. Questions could include: “What was the most important thing you learned today?“; “What important question remains unanswered?”; or “What was the muddiest point in _______ ?

View Details

Fishbowl

The Fishbowl Discussion is a teaching strategy that encourages full student participation, reflection, and depth of knowledge. A small group of students is selected to be the fish (in the fishbowl) while the rest of the class will be observers (out of the fishbowl). Students in the bowl participate in a discussion responding to an instructor prompt. Students outside of the bowl listen and reflect on the alternative viewpoints.

View Details

Pro and Con Grid

The Pro and Con Grid approach has students follow a decision-making process by reviewing an issue, creating a list of pro and con arguments, and making a decision based on the weight and analysis of those points. A review of students’ lists reveals the depth and breadth of their analyses, capacity for objectivity, and strength of their decision-making skills.

View Details

Think/Pair/Share

The Think/Pair/Share approach poses a question, asks students to reflect on the question, and has them share their ideas with others. Think has students reflect before speaking to organize their thoughts. Pair and Share ask students to compare and contrast their thoughts with others and rehearse their responses before sharing with the whole class.

View Details

Watch the video below to learn about three different types of interactions.

View video in Kaltura

[Download Transcript]

You should also read this article, Engagement Matters: Student Perceptions on the Importance of Engagement Strategies in the Online Learning Environment (Martin & Bolliger, 2018) to learn more about the types of interaction and which ones are most beneficial to students.

Reflect

Consider different ways to incorporate the three types of interaction in your own online course.


Asynchronous discussions

Asynchronous discussions are a nearly ubiquitous strategy used to enhance learning through interaction in online courses. There are many ways to approach asynchronous discussions, but here are a few key tips:

  1. Keep them small. Limit discussion groups to about 5-7 students to allow for relationships to develop and discussions to deepen.
  2. Set up staggered due dates. Clarify that first posts are due at least 3 days before final due date to ensure discussion can develop.
  3. Offer scaffolding to teach students how to discuss. Use sentence starters, roles, or clear instructions about how to post and how to reply.
  4. Use a rubric to clarify your expectations and make grading more efficient and equitable.

Resources for asynchronous discussions

Apply

Select a strategy to apply to your own online discussions.


Start resource series over